University of Michigan Law School
Civil Rights Litigation Clearinghouse
new search
page permalink
Case Name Duran v. Apodaca PC-NM-0001
Docket / Court 77-721 ( D.N.M. )
State/Territory New Mexico
Case Type(s) Prison Conditions
Attorney Organization ACLU National (all projects)
ACLU National Prison Project
Case Summary
In 1977, inmates of the Penitentiary of New Mexico, represented by the National Prison Project of the American Civil Liberties Union, filed a Section 1983 class action suit in the District of New Mexico against the governor of New Mexico and officials of the New Mexico Department of Corrections. ... read more >
In 1977, inmates of the Penitentiary of New Mexico, represented by the National Prison Project of the American Civil Liberties Union, filed a Section 1983 class action suit in the District of New Mexico against the governor of New Mexico and officials of the New Mexico Department of Corrections. In the First Amended Complaint, plaintiffs alleged that "the totality of the overcrowding and other conditions at PNM fall beneath standards of human decency, inflict needless suffering on prisoners and create an environment which threatens prisoners' mental and physical well-being, and results in the physical and mental deterioration and debilitation of the persons confined therein which is both unnecessary and penologically unjustifiable."

In 1979, the parties reached a settlement agreement–sometimes known as the Duran Consent Decree–which was adopted by the court. The original plaintiff, Dwight Duran, was released and began a life as an advocate for prisoners. In February 1980, 12 days after Duran was released, a massive prison riot broke out and the decree was modified. The modified decree focused on fourteen issues: correspondence, attorney visitation, food services, legal access, visitation, classification, living conditions, inmate activity, medical care, mental health care, staffing and training, administrative segregation, inmate discipline, and pre-hearing detention/disciplinary segregation. As part of the decree a special master was required to file a report every six months evaluating defendants' compliance.

There was periodic litigation throughout the 1980s regarding the implementation of the consent order. In 1986, plaintiffs successfully sought a preliminary injunction to halt prison staff layoffs with respect to medical care, mental health care and security. Duran v. Anaya, 642 F. Supp. 510 (D. N.M. 1986).

In 1988, prison officials moved to vacate portions of the consent decree. The District Court (Judge Juan G. Burciaga) denied the motion to vacate, holding that by presenting to the court an agreed remedial order, state officials waived their rights to restraint of comity in selection of equitable remedies. Duran v. Carruthers, 678 F. Supp. 839 (D. N.M. 1988). Defendants appealed. The Tenth Circuit (Judge McWilliams) affirmed the lower court decision, holding that the Eleventh Amendment did not bar the consent decree, even if some of the relief could not have been granted by the court under the Eleventh Amendment had the case gone to trial. Duran v. Carruthers, 885 F.2d 1485 (10th Cir. 1989).

Following renewed litigation, the parties agreed to a new settlement agreement in June 1991. The settlement agreement established new restrictions on overcrowding and modified provisions of the existing injunctive decree. The settlement agreement also established a timetable for monitoring and reporting by a special master. The monitoring process continued through the mid-1990's with Vincent M. Nathan and W. David Arnold acting as special master.

In December 1994, the plaintiffs sought contempt sanctions and further remedial orders; the parties settled the enforcement dispute in March 1995, with additional stipulated relief. But in January 1996, New Mexico began to move prisoners to Texas. The plaintiffs argued that this violated the prior agreements, and the Court granted a temporary restraining order enjoining the transfer. In March of that year, the parties agreed that the transfer of 350 medium security prisoners could go forward if the Texas facilities satisfied certain minimal standards, set out in the stipulation. (The parties amended the agreement in August 1997.)

During late 1996 or early 1997, Governor Gary Johnson vetoed a bill that would have set up a commission to oversee prison releases to deal with overcrowding at state prisons. At that point, the plaintiffs sought a population cap for the New Mexico Penitentiary, and Chief Judge Conway agreed to convene a three-judge district court to consider the request, pursuant to the Prison Litigation Reform Act (which limits such orders to narrow circumstances and requires they be considered by a specially convened three-judge panel). The panel met in March 1997, and scheduled an evidentiary hearing for September 1997. With that as the deadline, the parties reached an interim settlement, designed to reduce population by measures including increased use of diversion by drug courts and allowing inmates to regain lost good time under certain circumstances. The agreement was filed in August 1997; it put off any additional hearing on overcrowding for a few months. It seems that even though the agreement included population caps, the state agreed not to challenge them until April 1998.

Later in 1997, the parties agreed to a termination plan which provided "definitive, specific, and measurable tasks to be accomplished in order to achieve substantial compliance." The termination plan required check out audits by a special monitor and self-monitoring in all areas except for medical care. The termination plan also established December 1998 as a deadline for substantial compliance with the agreement. Following a finding of substantial compliance all orders were to be vacated.

The docket for this case only contains two entries from 1998 and 1999 regarding objections by defendants to a final report on mental health.

On December 9, 2015, an inmate not listed in the original action filed a motion for an emergency injunction, contempt, and a request for counsel. The case was then reassigned to District Judge Kenneth J. Gonzales and Magistrate Judge Gregory B. Wormuth as the trial and pretrial judges. A few days later the case was reassigned to Magistrate Judge Kirtan Khalsa. On February 19, 2016, Judge Khalsa denied the plaintiff's motion for counsel and mailed a copy of the Court's "Guide for Pro Se Litigants." Three days later the motion was refiled by the original class action plaintiffs. The parties had settlement conferences before Chief Magistrate Judge Karen B. Molzen on May 27, 2016 and August 5, 2016 to resolve the issues raised in the plaintiffs' motion for emergency relief. At the second conference they reached an agreement. The defendants agreed that any time they needed to put two occupants in a single cell, they would notify the court and plaintiffs' counsel 10 days before. They agreed to meet and confer in order to take good faith efforts to avoid "double-celling" inmates. The defendants also agreed to review and restore the good-time credits (credits inmates receive for good behavior) inmates lost for actions committed as a result of being doubled up in a single-cell; the plaintiffs' counsel would review these determinations. The court retained jurisdiction over the interpretation and enforcement of this settlement agreement.

On October 31, 2016, another inmate filed a motion for emergency relief and as of November 6, 2016, this matter is still pending.

Kristen Sagar - 08/07/2007
Abigail DeHart - 11/06/2016


compress summary

- click to show/hide ALL -
Issues and Causes of Action
click to show/hide detail
Issues
Affected Gender
Male
Content of Injunction
Preliminary relief granted
Crowding
Crowding / caseload
Post-PLRA Population Cap
General
Access to lawyers or judicial system
Administrative segregation
Assault/abuse by residents/inmates/students
Classification / placement
Disciplinary procedures
Disciplinary segregation
Food service / nutrition / hydration
Library (non-law) access
Mail
Recreation / Exercise
Sanitation / living conditions
Staff (number, training, qualifications, wages)
Totality of conditions
Visiting
Plaintiff Type
Private Plaintiff
Type of Facility
Government-run
Causes of Action 42 U.S.C. § 1983
Defendant(s) State Correctional Facilities
Plaintiff Description Inmates of the Penitentiary of New Mexico
Indexed Lawyer Organizations ACLU National (all projects)
ACLU National Prison Project
Class action status sought Yes
Class action status granted Yes
Prevailing Party Plaintiff
Public Int. Lawyer Yes
Nature of Relief Preliminary injunction / Temp. restraining order
Injunction / Injunctive-like Settlement
Source of Relief Settlement
Form of Settlement Court Approved Settlement or Consent Decree
Order Duration 1979 - n/a
Case Closing Year n/a
Case Ongoing Yes
Additional Resources
click to show/hide detail
Case Studies Civil Rights Injunctions Over Time: A Case Study of Jail and Prison Court Orders
N.Y.U. Law Review
By: Margo Schlanger (Washington University)
Citation: 81 N.Y.U. L. Rev. 550 (2006)
[ Detail ] [ PDF ] [ External Link ]

  Judicial Policy Making and the Modern State: How the Courts Reformed America's Prisons
By: Malcolm M. Feeley & Edward Rubin (UC Berkeley Boalt Hall School of Law & Vanderbilt School of Law Faculty)
Citation: (1998)
[ Detail ]

  The Duran Consent Decree: Analysis of Judicial Intervention on the State of New Mexico
By: Judith Ann Driscoll (University of New Mexico)
Citation: (1999) (unpublished Masters thesis, University of New Mexico)
[ Detail ]

Docket(s)
77-cv-721 (D.N.M.) 11/04/2016
PC-NM-0001-9001.pdf | Detail
PACER [Public Access to Court Electronic Records]
General Documents
Termination Plan-Part I & II
PC-NM-0001-0046.pdf | Detail
Order 04/18/1979 (D.N.M.)
PC-NM-0001-0002.pdf | Detail
Consent Decree (Agreement; Joint Request; Order) 04/18/1979
PC-NM-0001-0003.pdf | Detail
Order 08/21/1979 (D.N.M.)
PC-NM-0001-0004.pdf | Detail
Joint Request for Partial Consent Decree 12/07/1979
PC-NM-0001-0005.pdf | Detail
Order 12/07/1979 (D.N.M.)
PC-NM-0001-0006.pdf | Detail
Order 07/14/1980 (D.N.M.)
PC-NM-0001-0007.pdf | Detail
Agreement 07/14/1980
PC-NM-0001-0050.pdf | Detail
Agreement 06/01/1983
PC-NM-0001-0008.pdf | Detail
Order of Reference 06/03/1983 (D.N.M.)
PC-NM-0001-0009.pdf | Detail
Order 03/15/1984 (D.N.M.)
PC-NM-0001-0010.pdf | Detail
Stipulation Concerning Closing of Dormitories at the Penitentiary of New Mexico 04/20/1984
PC-NM-0001-0011.pdf | Detail
Order 04/20/1984 (D.N.M.)
PC-NM-0001-0012.pdf | Detail
Correspondence re: Proposed Modification of Maximum Security Policy Statement 06/26/1985
PC-NM-0001-0013.pdf | Detail
Motion to Modify the Inmate Discipline Policy Statement of the Consent Decree 06/27/1985
PC-NM-0001-0014.pdf | Detail
Memorandum in Support of Defendants' Motion to Modify the Maximum Security Policy Statement of the Consent Decree 07/11/1985 (D.N.M.)
PC-NM-0001-0015.pdf | Detail
Defendants' Motion to Modify the Maximum Security Policy Statement of the Consent Decree 07/11/1985
PC-NM-0001-0016.pdf | Detail
Memorandum Opinion 06/27/1986 (642 F.Supp. 510) (D.N.M.)
PC-NM-0001-0053.pdf | WESTLAW| LEXIS | Detail
Document Source: Google Scholar
Order 10/03/1986 (D.N.M.)
PC-NM-0001-0018.pdf | Detail
Reported Opinion 02/11/1988 (678 F.Supp. 839) (D.N.M.)
PC-NM-0001-0052.pdf | WESTLAW| LEXIS | Detail
Document Source: Google Scholar
Memorandum Decision 06/06/1988 (486 U.S. 1046)
PC-NM-0001-0056.pdf | WESTLAW| LEXIS | Detail
Document Source: Westlaw
Appendix to Petition for a Writ of Certiorari to the United States Court of Appeals for the Tenth Circuit 09/15/1989
PC-NM-0001-0022.pdf | Detail
Reported Opinion 09/15/1989 (885 F.2d 1485)
PC-NM-0001-0051.pdf | WESTLAW| LEXIS | Detail
Document Source: Google Scholar
Reported Opinion 09/15/1989 (885 F.2d 1492)
PC-NM-0001-0054.pdf | WESTLAW| LEXIS | Detail
Document Source: Google Scholar
Memorandum Decision 01/22/1990 (493 U.S. 1056)
PC-NM-0001-0055.pdf | WESTLAW| LEXIS | Detail
Document Source: Westlaw
Settlement Agreement 06/10/1991
PC-NM-0001-0024.pdf | Detail
Order 06/19/1991 (D.N.M.)
PC-NM-0001-0025.pdf | Detail
Order 09/20/1991 (D.N.M.)
PC-NM-0001-0026.pdf | Detail
Stipulation Between the Parties 01/29/1993
PC-NM-0001-0027.pdf | Detail
Order to Vacate Modified Decree at Central, Western and Southern New Mexico Correctional Facilities 01/29/1993 (D.N.M.)
PC-NM-0001-0028.pdf | Detail
Stipulation Regarding Fire Safety 02/16/1993
PC-NM-0001-0029.pdf | Detail
Order Approving Stipulation and Approving Employment of Expert 02/16/1993 (D.N.M.)
PC-NM-0001-0030.pdf | Detail
Order to Vacate Modified Decree, as to Inmate Activity, at the Central New Mexico Correctional Facility 12/21/1993 (D.N.M.)
PC-NM-0001-0031.pdf | Detail
First Stipulation on Inmate Activity 02/24/1994
PC-NM-0001-0033.pdf | Detail
Order Approving First Stipulation on Inmate Activity 02/25/1994 (D.N.M.)
PC-NM-0001-0034.pdf | Detail
Order 05/02/1994 (D.N.M.)
PC-NM-0001-0035.pdf | Detail
Second Stipulation on Inmate Activity 05/11/1994
PC-NM-0001-0036.pdf | Detail
Stipulation as to Penitentiary of New Mexico 03/02/1995
PC-NM-0001-0037.pdf | Detail
Unopposed Order Approving Stipulation and Dismissing Plaintiffs' Motion to Dismiss Motion for a Show Cause Order and for Further Remedial Orders 03/14/1995 (D.N.M.)
PC-NM-0001-0038.pdf | Detail
Motion for Temporary Restraining Order 01/29/1996
PC-NM-0001-0039.pdf | Detail
Memorandum in Support of Plaintiff's Request for Temporary Restraining Order and Preliminary Injunction. 01/29/1996
PC-NM-0001-0040.pdf | Detail
Stipulation 01/29/1996
PC-NM-0001-0045.pdf | Detail
Order 01/31/1996 (D.N.M.)
PC-NM-0001-0041.pdf | Detail
Amended Stipulation 08/11/1997
PC-NM-0001-0042.pdf | Detail
Order Approving Amended Stipulation and Suggesting Modification of Three-Judge Court's April 3, 1997 Order 08/11/1997 (D.N.M.)
PC-NM-0001-0043.pdf | Detail
Settlement Agreement 08/31/2016
PC-NM-0001-0057.pdf | Detail
Document Source: PACER [Public Access to Court Electronic Records]
Judges Burciaga, Juan Guerrero (D.N.M.)
PC-NM-0001-0008 | PC-NM-0001-0009 | PC-NM-0001-0010 | PC-NM-0001-0012 | PC-NM-0001-0018 | PC-NM-0001-0022 | PC-NM-0001-0025 | PC-NM-0001-0026 | PC-NM-0001-0028 | PC-NM-0001-0030 | PC-NM-0001-0031 | PC-NM-0001-0033 | PC-NM-0001-0034 | PC-NM-0001-0035 | PC-NM-0001-0038 | PC-NM-0001-0052 | PC-NM-0001-0053
Campos, Santiago E. (D.N.M.)
PC-NM-0001-0002 | PC-NM-0001-0004 | PC-NM-0001-0006 | PC-NM-0001-0007 | PC-NM-0001-0024 | PC-NM-0001-0050
Conway, John Edwards (D.N.M., FISC)
PC-NM-0001-0041 | PC-NM-0001-0043
Gonzales, Kenneth John (D.N.M.)
PC-NM-0001-0057 | PC-NM-0001-9001
Khalsa, Kirtan K Court not on record
PC-NM-0001-9001
McWilliams, Robert Hugh Jr. (Tenth Circuit)
PC-NM-0001-0051 | PC-NM-0001-0054
Seymour, Stephanie Kulp (Tenth Circuit)
PC-NM-0001-0022
Monitors/Masters Nathan, Vincent M. (Ohio)
PC-NM-0001-0039 | PC-NM-0001-9001
Plaintiff's Lawyers Alexander, Elizabeth R. (District of Columbia)
PC-NM-0001-0024 | PC-NM-0001-0051 | PC-NM-0001-0052 | PC-NM-0001-0054 | PC-NM-0001-9001
Bailey, Rothstein (New Mexico)
PC-NM-0001-0008
Bronstein, Alvin J. (District of Columbia)
PC-NM-0001-0022 | PC-NM-0001-0024 | PC-NM-0001-0051 | PC-NM-0001-0052 | PC-NM-0001-0054 | PC-NM-0001-9001
Cubra, Peter (New Mexico)
PC-NM-0001-0024 | PC-NM-0001-0057 | PC-NM-0001-9001
Davis, Philip B. (New Mexico)
PC-NM-0001-0054 | PC-NM-0001-9001
Deaton, William W. Jr. (New Mexico)
PC-NM-0001-0011 | PC-NM-0001-0012 | PC-NM-0001-0013
Donatelli, Mark H. (New Mexico)
PC-NM-0001-0024 | PC-NM-0001-0027 | PC-NM-0001-0029 | PC-NM-0001-0033 | PC-NM-0001-0034 | PC-NM-0001-0036 | PC-NM-0001-0037 | PC-NM-0001-0039 | PC-NM-0001-0040 | PC-NM-0001-0042 | PC-NM-0001-0045 | PC-NM-0001-0046 | PC-NM-0001-0051 | PC-NM-0001-0052 | PC-NM-0001-0057 | PC-NM-0001-9001
Fathi, David Cyrus (District of Columbia)
PC-NM-0001-9001
Gonzales, Dan (New Mexico)
PC-NM-0001-0027 | PC-NM-0001-9001
Kitts, W. F. (New Mexico)
PC-NM-0001-0022
Knowles, Ralph I. Jr. (Georgia)
PC-NM-0001-0003 | PC-NM-0001-0022
Lopez, Mark J. (District of Columbia)
PC-NM-0001-0051 | PC-NM-0001-0052 | PC-NM-0001-0054 | PC-NM-0001-9001
Macy, Edwin (New Mexico)
PC-NM-0001-0003 | PC-NM-0001-0022 | PC-NM-0001-0050
Twohig, R. Raymond Jr. (New Mexico)
PC-NM-0001-0008 | PC-NM-0001-0024 | PC-NM-0001-0051 | PC-NM-0001-0052 | PC-NM-0001-0053 | PC-NM-0001-9001
Winterbottom, Richard A. (New Mexico)
PC-NM-0001-0027 | PC-NM-0001-0039 | PC-NM-0001-0040 | PC-NM-0001-0045 | PC-NM-0001-9001
Defendant's Lawyers Amada, M. Victoria (New Mexico)
PC-NM-0001-9001
Becker, Robert W. (New Mexico)
PC-NM-0001-9001
Bieg, James (New Mexico)
PC-NM-0001-0022 | PC-NM-0001-0051
Biernoff, Ari (New Mexico)
PC-NM-0001-0057 | PC-NM-0001-9001
Bigelow, John (New Mexico)
PC-NM-0001-0008 | PC-NM-0001-0011 | PC-NM-0001-0012 | PC-NM-0001-0013 | PC-NM-0001-0014 | PC-NM-0001-0015 | PC-NM-0001-0016 | PC-NM-0001-0053
Bohnhoff, Henry M. (New Mexico)
PC-NM-0001-0022 | PC-NM-0001-0051
Booms, Robert Tabor (New Mexico)
PC-NM-0001-0024 | PC-NM-0001-0027 | PC-NM-0001-0029 | PC-NM-0001-0033 | PC-NM-0001-0034 | PC-NM-0001-0036 | PC-NM-0001-0037 | PC-NM-0001-0039 | PC-NM-0001-0042 | PC-NM-0001-0045 | PC-NM-0001-0046 | PC-NM-0001-9001
Byers, Frederick (Ohio)
PC-NM-0001-9001
Childress, Randall W. (New Mexico)
PC-NM-0001-0054
Cohen, Saul (New Mexico)
PC-NM-0001-0022 | PC-NM-0001-0051 | PC-NM-0001-0054
Cohn, Bennett S. (New Mexico)
PC-NM-0001-9001
Hoffman, Robyn B. (New Mexico)
PC-NM-0001-9001
Kaser, Martha J. (New Mexico)
PC-NM-0001-0054
Kelly, Martha A. (New Mexico)
PC-NM-0001-9001
Klein, Joel I. (District of Columbia)
PC-NM-0001-0022 | PC-NM-0001-0051 | PC-NM-0001-0054 | PC-NM-0001-9001
Mederios, Anthony F. (New Mexico)
PC-NM-0001-9001
Peifer, Charles R. (New Mexico)
PC-NM-0001-0054
Roybal, Randall D. (New Mexico)
PC-NM-0001-9001
Ryanczak, Regina (New Mexico)
PC-NM-0001-0057 | PC-NM-0001-9001
Smith, Paul M. (District of Columbia)
PC-NM-0001-0022 | PC-NM-0001-0051 | PC-NM-0001-0054
Stratton, Hal (New Mexico)
PC-NM-0001-0022 | PC-NM-0001-0051 | PC-NM-0001-0054
Thayer, Norman S. (New Mexico)
PC-NM-0001-0022 | PC-NM-0001-0051 | PC-NM-0001-0052 | PC-NM-0001-0054 | PC-NM-0001-9001
Udall, Tom (New Mexico)
PC-NM-0001-0024 | PC-NM-0001-0029 | PC-NM-0001-0033 | PC-NM-0001-0034 | PC-NM-0001-0045
W., David Arnold (Ohio)
PC-NM-0001-9001
Wilson, Stephany S. (New Mexico)
PC-NM-0001-0022 | PC-NM-0001-0051 | PC-NM-0001-0054 | PC-NM-0001-9001
Other Lawyers Eikenberry, Kenneth O. (Washington)
PC-NM-0001-0051
Farley, Paul (Colorado)
PC-NM-0001-0022 | PC-NM-0001-0051
Frohnmayer, David B. (Oregon)
PC-NM-0001-0051
Meyer, Joseph B. (Wyoming)
PC-NM-0001-0051
Michaels, Steven S. (Hawaii)
PC-NM-0001-0051
Price, Warren III (Hawaii)
PC-NM-0001-0051
Stephan, Robert T. (Kansas)
PC-NM-0001-0022 | PC-NM-0001-0051
Wilkinson, David L. (Utah)
PC-NM-0001-0022 | PC-NM-0001-0051

- click to show/hide ALL -

new search
page permalink

- top of page -